Disney’s ABC has submitted its license renewal applications to the FCC as ordered by the agency — but it is doing so “under protest.”
The FCC’s Media Bureau last month issued an unprecedented order forcing ABC to reapply for spectrum licenses for its eight owned-and-operated stations on an accelerated schedule. The move came after President Trump called for Jimmy Kimmel to be fired over a joke the late-night host made about First Lady Melania Trump. The FCC officially says the early ABC license review is pursuant to the agency’s investigation into Disney and ABC’s potential violations of discrimination rules via the media conglomerate’s diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) practices.
But ABC argues in its license-renewal application that the FCC order’s “true purpose and inescapable effect are to suppress speech — to ramp up toward possible license revocation and cause the Station and others to think twice before they say something the government might dislike.” As such, ABC says, the order violates the First Amendment.
In its filing for New York’s WABC-TV, the network said the FCC’s order was “unlawful, arbitrary and unconstitutional.” The spectrum licenses for the eight ABC-owned stations were not due to come up for renewal until 2028 at the earliest, with some not due until 2031 — and the FCC’s demand for early review of ABC’s TV station licenses is unprecedented.
“The Commission had not demanded early renewal in over five decades. And it has never before demanded simultaneous license renewal applications from a group of stations commonly owned with a network as it has here,” ABC’s application said.
The network continued, “The Order has no legitimate purpose. There is no information that the application will reveal that the Commission could not obtain through other means. The Order is inconsistent with a legitimate exercise of investigative authority and is plainly incompatible with the First Amendment. Worse, the Order opens the door to an assault on the Station’s license, while the Commission searches for a legal pretext to achieve its desired goal. This effort to suppress speech under the guise of bureaucratic process must not prevail. WABC files this application without waiving any rights, and calls on the Commission to rescind the Order.”
The FCC “has elsewhere committed to identifying and eliminating obsolete or unnecessary regulations. Here, it does the opposite — excavating an arcane procedural relic, dormant for decades, to justify its actions,” the WABC filing says. “The ‘call-up’ provision that it now invokes was designed for a regulatory world that no longer exists: an era of shorter license terms, comparative hearings weighing applicants’ merits, and exhaustive renewal showings on program content. That world is gone.”
ABC said the FCC’s claim that it ordered the early license renewal review because it is investigating Disney’s ABC stations for “possible violations” of the agency’s prohibition on unlawful discrimination rationale “does not survive scrutiny. The path for investigating any such potential violations is obviously through the investigation of that very subject which the Commission began in June 2025 and has been ongoing since then.”
The WABC filing said that Disney has produced over 11,000 pages of responsive documents “on a mutually agreed schedule” and that the FCC’s Enforcement Bureau “has never suggested its existing tools are insufficient for whatever it is investigating, and has elsewhere touted those same tools as providing ‘broad statutory authority to investigate any question that may arise under any of the provisions of the Act.’”
Leave a Reply