Newsmax Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Fox Corp. Over Roku Acquisition

Written by

in

Newsmax has filed an antitrust lawsuit challenging Fox Corp.‘s $22 billion acquisition of Roku, a transaction that was closed earlier this month.

In the lawsuit, filed in federal court in San Jose, claimed that the Justice Department “allowed this merger to an effective monopoly to close unchallenged,” while Newsmax’s legal team dismissed a set of commitments that Fox made as “ill-defined” and with “no evident enforcement mechanism.”

Newsmax contended that Roku’s Roku Channel with Fox’s Tubi have a combined 70% share in the market for free ad supported television streaming channels.

“DOJ virtually never clears a transaction combining the two leading competitors in a concentrated market; it typically demands divestiture of one or the other to protect competition,” Newsmax’s legal team wrote in their lawsuit.

A Fox Corp. spokesperson said in a statement, “Newsmax’s complaint, which comes after a rigorous review process by regulatory agencies, is wholly without merit. Upon closing, we commenced actively integrating this approved transaction for the benefit of consumers, partners and other stakeholders.”

Last year, Newsmax filed an antitrust lawsuit against Fox News claiming that it was suppressing competition in the market for right-leaning video content. A federal judge in Florida dismissed the complaint as a “shotgun pleading.” When the case was then filed in Wisconsin, a federal judge there found that it was a form of “forum shopping” and ordered it transferred to Florida. The case is still pending there, with discovery stayed as a judge considers Fox’s motion to dismiss.

Fox and Roku announced the closing of their transaction on the morning of Nov. 6, less than five months after the deal was proposed last June – well ahead of the initially projected window of the first half of 2027. Later that day, the Justice Department announced in a press release that it had cleared the transaction, outlining the set of commitments that Fox made as it sought the regulatory greenlight. Among them was one promising that Roku would “remain an open and neutral content partner post-merger,” and that Roku would continue to carry non-Fox content on for a period of at least three years.

In their Roku lawsuit, Newsmax’s legal team argued that “when a transaction is likely to harm competition absent conduct remedies of the sort to which Fox supposedly ‘committed,’ DOJ’s practice is to negotiate a consent decree that sets out those commitments.” The consent decree is released by the public and reviewed by the court under the Tunney Act, Newsmax’s lawyers noted.

“That procedure ensures that the merging parties’ obligations are clear and enforceable – something four bullet points in a press release fail to achieve,” Newsmax’s legal team wrote.

Newsmax claimed that after the announcement of the merger close, it contacted Fox to ask for a binding contract to make its commitments enforceable. Newsmax sent a term sheet, per the lawsuit, but Fox rejected it and declined to make a counter proposal

Newsmax’s legal team wrote, “As the press release effectively acknowledges, Fox’s ownership of Roku creates substantial vertical foreclosure concerns: a leading content provider will control its competitors’ access to a critical distribution channel. At a minimum, those concerns must be addressed through enforceable behavioral conditions that prevent Fox from disadvantaging rival content providers.”

Newsmax claimed that Fox has refused to carry its news channel on Tubi, and that with the acquisition of The Roku Channel “the risk that Fox will further degrade distribution of Newsmax’s content is clear.”

The lawsuit called for injunctive relief, including the unwinding of the merger unless Fox divests Tubi or The Roku Channel.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *