Death row inmate’s chilling final words before being executed for double murder

Written by

in

Death row inmate Thomas Mitchell Overton has been put to death in Florida, marking the state’s record-breaking 20th execution this year.

Overton, 71, was given the death penalty for the 1991 murders of 30-year-old Michael MacIvor and his 29-year-old pregnant wife Susan, known as Missy in Tavernier, Florida.

Overton was caught for the crimes five years later after he was arrested on an unrelated robbery case after samples of his DNA matched semen found at the crime scene.

Investigators also discovered that Overton had met Missy in the days before her murder, with the 29-year-old telling her sister-in-law about a ‘creepy’ Amoco gas station attendant that had attempted to hit on her.

The attendant was later identified as Overton.

The case eventually went to court in 1999, where a fellow inmate testified that Overton had confessed to killing the couple.

Overton was found guilty of the double murder and was given the death penalty.

He was also sentenced to life in prison for burglary and rape, plus 15 years for the murder of the couple’s unborn child.

Thomas Mitchell Overton has become the 20th person to be executed in Florida this year (Matt McClain/ The Washington Post via Getty Images)

Thomas Mitchell Overton has become the 20th person to be executed in Florida this year (Matt McClain/ The Washington Post via Getty Images)

After spending more than two decades on death row, Overton was pronounced dead at 6:19pm local time after being given the lethal injection at Florida State Prison in Raiford.

With his final words, Overton attempted to deny the horrific crimes.

“I’ve never sexually assaulted anyone. I never killed anyone,” Overton said.

“I didn’t kill the MacIvors.”

After he shared his final words, the execution got underway with Overton ‘panting and gasping heavily for about a minute’ before slumping over, the Associated Press reports.

A warden then called Overton’s name and shook him, before a medic pronounced him dead.

Florida department of corrections spokesperson, Jordan Kirkland told a news conference that Overton did not meet with any visitors or spiritual advisors on the day of his execution.

Michael MacIvor’s sister, two brothers and cousin witnessed the execution.

Speaking to the Associated Press afterwards, his sister Sharon said watching it had given her a sense of relief.

‘Justice has been served’

In a statement, Monroe State Attorney Dennis Ward, said Overton was a ‘cold-blooded killer’ and that the execution would serve as closure following ‘more than three decades of legal proceedings’.

Michael and Missy MacIvor were murdered in 1991 (Family handout)

Michael and Missy MacIvor were murdered in 1991 (Family handout)

“He destroyed an entire family for no reason other than his own sick and twisted desires,” Ward said, according to the Miami Herald.

“Justice has been served, but no execution can undo the suffering he caused or return three innocent lives. Michael, Missy, and Kyle Patrick MacIvor will never be forgotten.”

Overton’s execution is the 20th to take place in Florida so far this year, breaking last year’s previous record of 19.

This means the state has now carried out more than half of the US’s 39 executions in 2026.

Outgoing Republican Governor Ron DeSantis has previously said he wanted to provide justice to the families of victims who have waited decades for death sentences to be carried out.

As well as the 20 executions that have already taken place, Florida has two more planned for next month.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *