Are the videos of flying pterodactyls real? The experts give their verdict

Written by

in

A screen grab of the viral 'pterodactyl' video in Mexico.
A real-life pterodactyl? Maybe. An AI-generated video? More likely

Is it a bird? Is it a plane? No, that massive thing flying in the sky is a leathery-winged creature that lived in the time of the dinosaurs.

Pterodactyls are a family of carnivorous reptiles, some as small as pigeons, that flapped 150million years ago over Europe and Africa.

But apparently, one of these beasts has been spotted in Ciudad Juárez, a city in Chihuahua, Mexico.

Footage of the sightings has gone viral on social media after Mexican journalist and UFOlogist Jaime Maussan shared them on X.

So Metro showed these videos to two experts in AI-generated imagery – the results might not be what you’d expect.

What are the pterodactyl videos?

Sightings have been shared on Instagram, Facebook and Threads in recent days and have gone viral.

‘I’m sorry. I know we all have a lot going on. But I really feel like no one is sufficiently losing their minds enough about this f***ing pterodactyl,’ a user on Threads said.

Most clips show a pterodactyl-shaped… things soaring over Abraham González International Airport and roosting on radio towers.

One was said to have been picked up by a home security camera in Juárez Valley, while a second was recorded in Ciudad Juárez.

Maussan suggested that the beings may have slipped into our universe through ‘interdimensional portals’ torn open in the Juárez Valley.

His YouTube show, Interestelar, aired a video said to be filmed by a young boy at 11pm on November 7 in Ciudad Juárez’s Felipe Ángeles neighbourhood.

‘The strange creature attacked a dog and tried to carry it away, releasing it at the last moment. It then took flight,’ the report said.

Follow Metro on WhatsApp to be the first to get all the latest news

Apps With More Than One Million Users
Follow us to receive the latest news updates from Metro (Picture: Getty Images)

Metro’s on Whatsapp! Join our community for breaking news and juicy stories.

More videos compiled by Ovniologia, an alien hunter blogger, show the creature has pointed wings and a long beak.

Another X user claimed a witness heard ‘bird’ noises and the sound of wings beating overhead.

‘The dogs were apparently barking at the enormous animal,’ they added.

Maussan, however, did suggest on Interestelar these beasts might actually not be pterodactyls.

Instead, they’re clearly pteranodons, one of the largest flying creatures known that glide using wings made of stretchable membrane.

Such sightings have happened before. In 2015, a video ‘captured by an amateur filmmaker’ and shared on YouTube showed a ‘pterodactyl’ soaring over the skies of Boise, Idaho.

So… is it real?

No. For one, as the fact-checking service Snopes and the local authorities point out, pterodactyls, properly known as pterodactyloids, have been extinct for millions of years.

So, were the videos generated using AI? The footage does have a few tell-tale signs, says Nathan Marlor, head of data and AI at Version 1.

In the pterodactyl sightings, the creature’s wings often change shape from frame to frame, Malor says.

‘At some points it looks like it has a third wing, or two wings stacked on one side. A real animal’s wings stay the same shape as they flap,’ he says.

The flapping is also a giveaway, with the reptile’s wingbeats being identical every time, something that doesn’t happen with real flying animals.

‘The wing movement looks painted on rather than doing any real work,’ Marlor adds.

A winged silhouette – probably not a flying reptile, though, over Juárez Valley

Generative AI is getting better at fooling people with realistic-looking images and videos but often gets details wrong, like smearing text.

This happens, Malor says, because the machines forge things they don’t understand by ‘redrawing’ them constantly.

But the tech is getting better at fooling people – even the software designed to spot it – setting off concerns about disinformation and discrimination.

A report from VerifyLabs.AI, which can check whether an image was made from a photo or AI, for example, said the results were ‘inconclusive’.

Still, as the tool’s co-founder, Ruth Azar-Knupffer, says, this doesn’t prove the clips are authentic by any means.

An AI detection tool report.
An AI detection tool report on one of the videos (Picture: VerifyLabs.AI)

Rather, the footage is grainy and compressed, meaning the media has been squished to take up less storage, making AI signs harder to spot.

‘That matters because AI-deepfake and synthetic media bad actors often keep the resolution low on purpose so the footage can’t be properly analysed,’ says Azar-Knupffer.

As ‘quaint’ as a few people believing the videos are legitimate may seem, he adds, that isn’t a good thing.

‘We’re wired to believe what we see, and synthetic media is removing our ability to tell real from fake,’ Azar-Knupffer says.

‘This has massive implications for every area of human society – from personal relationships to voting for governments.’

Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.

For more stories like this, check our news page.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *